Slots & casino industry news Newsletter RSS
Land-Based Casinos

CFTC sports contract swap rule draws 140 comments as tribes lead opposition

The CFTC proposal to treat sports event contracts as swaps drew 140 comments, with tribal groups leading opposition and prediction market operators in support.

The Las Vegas Strip at night with the Bellagio fountains and the Eiffel Tower replica
Photo: Stephen Leonardi / Pexels · Pexels License

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) proposal to explicitly include sports event contracts in the definition of swaps drew 140 public comments by the November 18 deadline. Most of the comments arrived in the final two days of the comment period. Prediction market operators and financial industry participants supported federal oversight, while tribal organizations led the opposition. Opposition also came from a coalition of 43 states and Washington, D.C., the American Gaming Association (AGA), the governor and attorney general of Utah, and Nevada lawmaker Dina Titus. Earlier CFTC comment periods drew far more responses, as an April advance notice of proposed rulemaking attracted over 3,500 comments and a July proposal drew over 1,400.

Tribal opposition

The National Congress of American Indians (NCAI), which represents approximately 300 tribal nations, called for the proposal’s withdrawal. “Simply labeling these wagers as swaps does not change their underlying nature as gambling,” NCAI wrote. The Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria warned that sporting event contracts offered by prediction markets threaten the entire economic foundation of tribal governments. Three of the four tribes that partnered with Kalshi submitted supporting comments, with only the Kletsel Dehe Wintun Nation not filing a comment. The Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town argued that federally regulated event contracts and tribal gaming can coexist under separate regulatory frameworks without undermining IGRA.

States and industry

The state coalition urged the CFTC to withdraw the proposal, arguing that the agency lacks statutory authority to redefine sports wagering as financial derivatives. The AGA argued that the proposed framework would create unequal treatment for products it considers functionally identical. It also questioned whether the CFTC understands the size of the sports event contract market, as the agency’s assessment points to $1.5 billion in monthly trading activity while the figure stood at over $39 billion in the first week of November alone. Boyd Gaming warned that an overly broad swap definition could eventually encompass traditional casino games.

Operators back the rule

Operators including Kalshi, Polymarket US and Coinbase endorsed the inclusion of event contracts within the swap definition. Coinbase maintained that qualifying event contracts are already swaps under federal law. Underdog disclosed that its exchange has self-certified more than 500 sports event contracts as swaps. Gemini recommended several changes to strengthen the rules against potential legal challenges. The CFTC must now consider the submissions as it determines whether to finalize or revise the proposal.

Sources

  1. Gambling Insider · Industry media · primary source ·

Spotted a mistake? Report an error — see our corrections policy.

CFTCkalshi Sports betting handleUSA